Key Takeaways
A job site is cheaper up front, but you do the sourcing, screening, and management.
An agency costs more, but it handles vetting and replacements and saves you weeks.
Job sites suit small, defined tasks. Agencies suit long-term dedicated roles.
Value your own time honestly before choosing the do-it-yourself route.
The Short Answer
On a job site like Upwork, you find and check people yourself. With a recruiter, they find and check people and you choose. Both can work. It depends on how much time you have.
Side By Side
Job site | Recruiter | |
|---|---|---|
Finding people | You | The recruiter |
Checking them | You | The recruiter |
Your time | More | Less |
Control | Every step | You pick from a shortlist |
Best for | People who enjoy hiring | Busy owners |
A Job Site Is Good If…
You have hiring experience and time
You want to try a few people cheaply
The task is short or small
A Recruiter Is Good If…
You want a long-term helper who is checked first
You would rather meet three strong people than read fifty applications
Add up the hours you would spend on the job post, reading applications, and interviews. If that time is worth more than the fee, a recruiter can be a better fit. We are a recruiter, so compare with your own numbers.
What You Get On Each Path
On a marketplace like Upwork you post a job, receive proposals from anyone, and screen them yourself. The platform handles contracts, time tracking, and payments for a fee. An agency does the screening for you, presents a shortlist, and charges a placement fee or a monthly rate.
Time Versus Money
Marketplaces are cheaper and take more of your time. Expect dozens or hundreds of applications and plan a weekend for screening. Agencies cost more and take days of your time instead of weeks. First-time hirers and owners hiring senior roles usually come out ahead with an agency.
Quality And Risk
Both draw from the same regions. The marketplace pool is wider and more mixed; agencies pre-filter. Marketplace payment protection reduces financial risk; agency guarantee windows reduce the risk of a bad hire.
A Practical Approach
Use a marketplace for part-time or project work when you have time to screen.
Use an agency for full-time roles or when your time is worth more than the fee.
Run a paid test task on either path.
Questions Owners Ask
Can I move an Upwork hire off the platform?
Upwork's terms restrict this for a period after the first contract. Read them before you plan to.
Do agencies use Upwork to find people?
Some source from job boards and platforms. Ask where their candidates come from and what screening they add.
Written by
Hire A Virtual Assistant Team
Editorial Team
Practical guides on hiring, managing, and working with remote virtual assistants.
Ready To Hire A Virtual Assistant?
Tell us the role and the hours. We find and vet the candidates, and you choose who joins your team.
Industries
Who Uses These Roles
FAQ
Common Questions
Short, simple answers.
Is A Recruiter Worth It Compared With A Marketplace?
Can I Use Both?
Keep Reading
More Guides
Ready To Hire A Virtual Assistant?
Tell us the role and the hours. We find and vet the candidates, and you choose who joins your team.