Key Takeaways
The key differences between providers are recruiting quality, pricing transparency, who the staff report to, and what happens when a hire does not work out.
Ask to see the tests candidates complete and insist on choosing your own hire.
Beware of markups hidden inside monthly fees, and of models where you never meet the person.
The best fit for most small businesses is a managed recruiting service with dedicated staff who report to you.
The Main Models
Seat-based BPO: staff sit in the provider's office, follow the provider's processes, and you pay a monthly seat fee. Best for large, uniform teams.
Managed staffing: the provider recruits and employs the person, who works for you remotely. You pay a monthly fee that bundles salary and margin.
Managed recruiting: the provider recruits, tests, and introduces candidates. You choose, the person works for you, and pay is transparent.
Marketplaces: you find and manage freelancers yourself. See Upwork vs a virtual assistant agency.
Question 1: How Do You Recruit And Test?
Ask to see the actual tests: writing samples, skills assessments, scenario interviews. Ask what percentage of applicants make it to a shortlist. A provider that cannot describe its process in detail probably does not have one. Our own process is on the how it works page.
Question 2: Do I Choose The Person?
Some providers assign staff. You should interview and pick. The person will work with you every day, and fit matters. Ask what happens if nobody on the shortlist fits. The right answer is that you do not hire anyone and the search continues.
Question 3: What Is In The Price?
Ask for the split between what the worker receives and what the provider keeps. Large hidden markups mean the worker is underpaid, which drives turnover. Ask about setup fees, minimum terms, and what happens to the rate at renewal. Our pricing models guide explains the common structures.
Question 4: Who Does The Person Report To?
You should direct the work. Providers that insert a supervisor between you and your staff slow everything down and dilute accountability. Support from the provider is good. A layer of management you did not ask for is not.
Question 5: What Is The Guarantee?
Ask what happens if the hire leaves or does not work out in the first months. A replacement at no extra cost within a reasonable window is standard for good providers. Ask how many placements they replace, and why.
Question 6: What Support Comes After Placement?
Help with onboarding, payments, holidays, and problems is valuable. Ask what the provider does in month two and month six, not just in week one. Read how to evaluate virtual assistant companies for a broader checklist.
Red Flags
No written test results for candidates.
Refusal to disclose the worker's share of the fee.
Long minimum contracts with penalties.
You cannot contact the worker directly.
Guarantees that expire before the person has finished training.
What This Looks Like In Practice
A software company compares three providers for two support hires. Provider A quotes a monthly seat fee but will not say how much the worker receives, and assigns staff without interviews. Provider B is a marketplace where the owner would screen hundreds of applicants himself. Provider C describes a testing process, shares sample test results, offers a shortlist of three per role, and shows the pay split.
The company chooses C. Two weeks later they interview six tested candidates, hire two, and the staff report directly to the support lead. When one hire leaves after four months for a family reason, the provider replaces her within three weeks at no charge. The owner's rule afterward: if you cannot see the tests and the pay split, walk away.
A Quick Checklist Before You Start
Ask each provider to describe its testing process and show examples.
Confirm you interview and choose.
Get the pay split and every fee in writing.
Confirm the person reports to you.
Read the guarantee and replacement terms.
Ask what support looks like at month two and month six.
Six questions, one afternoon, and you will know which provider deserves your hires.
Questions Owners Ask
Is A Big BPO Better Than A Small Provider?
Not for small businesses. Large BPOs are built for teams of dozens with uniform processes. A managed recruiting service fits one-to-ten hires better.
Should The Provider Employ The Person Or Should I Contract Directly?
Either can work. Direct contracting is simpler and more transparent. Provider employment adds local compliance for larger teams.
How Long Should Recruiting Take?
Two to three weeks from brief to shortlist is typical for a good provider. Faster often means less testing.
Written by
Hire A Virtual Assistant Team
Editorial Team
Practical guides on hiring, managing, and working with remote virtual assistants.
Ready To Hire A Virtual Assistant?
Tell us who you need. We recruit, screen and introduce vetted candidates, and you choose who to hire.
FAQ
Common Questions
Short, simple answers.
Is This A Freelancer Marketplace?
No. We are a recruiting service. You don’t browse profiles or post a job and sort through applicants. We recruit against your brief and introduce candidates who match, so you spend your time interviewing rather than searching.
Who Makes The Final Hiring Decision?
You do. We recruit, screen and introduce candidates, but the decision to hire is yours, based on your own interviews and your own standards.
How Do You Vet Candidates?
We review experience, English communication, software skills and role-specific ability, and speak with candidates directly. The exact screening depends on the role, for example a writing test for content roles or a call assessment for phone roles.
Keep Reading
More Guides
Ready To Hire A Virtual Assistant?
Tell us who you need. We recruit, screen and introduce vetted candidates, and you choose who to hire.




